The traditional method of providing constructive criticism/feedback would sound something like this:
Performance Management Blog
Topics: feedback, addressing bad behaviors, Address Performance Issues, managing workplace behavior issues, manager avoiding performance conversations, constructive criticism, improving performance, managing difficult discussions, managing bad employee behaviors, address bad behavior, difficult employees, disruptive behavior, employee performance issue
I continually hear from employees who have just had their performance evaluation that it wasn't a valuable developmental experience. I then ask, "Did you learn what you do well and should continue doing and find out at least one thing you could be doing that would help you be more effective"? About 10% will answer yes to that question.